Reflections on my winding path through Community Organizing and into Investment Advising
October 2026
Mac Liman
Investment Advisor, Nubian Square Investment Advisors

For a long time, my work of building an equitable economy happened on the “giving” side of the table: in nonprofits, in campaigns, in donor organizing, and in the program and grantmaking work of philanthropy. I recently made a big transition to the community-based finance and “investment” side of this work, and am now proud to be an Investment Advisor for Nubian Square Investment Advisors. I don’t think of this as having left one place for another; I think of it as a widening of the strategy. And yet, there are clear cultural and practical differences, each with their own strengths and pitfalls. I can now see each side with more clarity and humility. Allow me to share:
Movement organizations, when at our best…
- aim to build people power and change policy. Movements for social change know that lasting change takes people and resources who are organized enough to change the policies that govern our society and institutions.
- move at the speed of trust. Movement spaces value long-term relationships and ask what our decisions today will mean for generations to come. They don’t underestimate the need for and power of repair and emotional wellbeing. They stay close to the why – including identity and personal story – which other spaces can sometimes set aside.
- collaborate across sectors. We use those deep relationships across sectors to build coalitions – nonprofits, formal and informal community groups, governments, philanthropy, businesses, academia, donors, and beyond. We see our interconnection and find common goals across interests, impact, identity, geography and more.
- ask “should we?” Nonprofits and movements pause to ask whether something is right before asking how to do it. That question has protected communities from many harms.
- care for the whole person. We often start our work by breathing together, arriving, grounding. We talk about what this work does to our bodies and hearts. We integrate ritual and culture. “Check ins” can sometimes take up a little too long in a meeting agenda, and this holistic care is also clearly part of what makes the work deepen and last.
- develop partnerships and have clear roles with donors and funders. We know this is no small feat, but not impossible. Despite challenging power dynamics we know it’s essential to shift from transactional financial relationships to ones grounded in trust and accountability. Some in our sector go even further to support donors and funders to become agents of change within their own networks, contributing more to movements than money alone.
- build creative programs to meet immediate needs. Many nonprofits were created in response to mountains of real and immediate unmet needs. Food, housing, healthcare, education, transportation, cultural healing and more. The urgent need for direct services for our people sometimes keeps us in a reactionary mindset or pulls us away from creating change upstream, but meeting these needs is also an act of love and resilience, and when integrated appropriately, is essential to building collective power.
Finance and corporate businesses, when community-based and at their best…
- pivot quickly. When something isn’t working, we change course. Rather than hosting a strategic planning retreat about it or defaulting to a future quarter, we notice when something isn’t working or a mistake was made, and *gasp* do something different. When seventh generation thinking about people and the planet are integrated, this pace has the potential to actually meet the moment.
- ask “how do we do this well?” Corporate culture can be skilled at designing efficient, practical ways to make an idea real, and at sticking with it until it works. Sometimes the individual and collective impacts (especially those that are harder to quantify and measure) get sacrificed along the way, but at its best, this drive for excellence produces just that: excellence.
- use traditional tools on purpose. The financial systems we live in have caused real harm, past and present, and we’re living with the consequences every day. And the tools of financial systems (banks, investments, entities, contracts, markets, etc) are not inherently harmful. Combining finance and activism means putting these structures to work for an equitable economy, with eyes wide open to their history.
- build institutions for the future. Without the same pressures to react, control by funders, and regulatory limitations, for-profit and corporate institutions are sometimes freer to build proactively, try new models, and aim for innovation.
- welcome growth and scale. For-profit finance is expected to use money as a tool for its ends and grow where it can. Many nonprofits are pushed to compete for scarce charitable dollars and are also often criticized, and limited, in how they grow their staff, reach and impact. Movement and activist spaces – in our deep and embodied awareness of the harms of extractive economies – associate money and growth with the systems that have hurt our people so much. These dynamics combined can make the difference between thinking – and acting – in thousands and thinking in billions. When the “ends” we seek are shared prosperity and our governance structures align, we have a greater chance of building a regenerative economy to scale.
- develop partnerships with investors. Much as “donor organizers” support individuals and institutions to develop an identity and practice around their giving so that they can support movements for the long haul, finance has created templates and pathways to “Investor identity.” Most donors and foundations, however, have 10x more money invested in the stock market than they give away each year. And yet, many donors and foundations do not have a clear understanding of their own role as investors nor the relationship – positive or negative – between their giving and investing.
- attain economic upside and keep it in community. Dominate economics knows how to build structures that absorb returns and circulate that value. Most businesses are structured and incentivized to funnel wealth to the top. When we choose to prioritize community, we can make sure the benefits of businesses stay with workers, entrepreneurs, the land, and consumers, as well as investors. Campaigns and power building often open this door, and financial policy keeps the capital flowing in communities.
The traditions of movement organizations offer hope in the form of creative, beautiful vision. They remind us that “if you want to go far, go together,” and they tend to our whole selves along the way.
Values-aligned corporate culture offers hope in the form of confident momentum, mastery of tools we can’t afford to ignore, and the ability to apply our values at scale.
Each lineage is incomplete without the other. Vision without resources can stay out of reach. Resources without vision can repeat old harms. Movements win the policies and build the people power that change what’s possible, and finance builds the structures that ensure communities own and keep the benefits of those wins. At Nubian Square Investment Advisors, we hold both. We ask “should we do it?” and “how do we do it best?” We build institutions that repair and institutions that innovate. We infuse the practice of donor organizing into our work so that wealthy donors and foundations – and others who may not be able to see themselves as part of this world – can truly move into their full power as investors. We move with trust and with momentum. I’m grateful to the many of you – past and present – who creatively strive in both traditions. And to the colleagues, clients, and partners who let us practice this together every day.